2011 Berkshire Hathaway Annual Meeting

Lessons from this meeting:

  1. Be Willing to Pay for Quality, but Mind the Price
    • Even great businesses (e.g. BYD) can become overvalued—if you still believe in the long-term fundamentals, expect short-term glitches and stay the course.
    • The cheaper the entry price relative to intrinsic value, the larger your margin of safety; once you’ve paid up, patience—not headstrong buying—is your best defense.
  2. Speculating in Commodities Is a Tough Game
    • If you can reliably predict oil (or any commodity) prices, you shouldn’t be running complex businesses—you’d just sit in a room trading commodities.
    • Instead, focus on productive assets (railroads, insurers, manufacturers) where you can identify durable competitive advantages.
  3. Don’t Hedge Commodities at the Parent Level
    • Berkshire’s policy is to let its operating subsidiaries hedge their own commodity exposures—but the parent company doesn’t try to “guess” oil, copper, or cotton prices.
    • If you think you can forecast a commodity’s direction over the next year, odds are you don’t have an edge; better to invest in businesses you understand.
  4. Align Incentives by Making Stakes Meaningful
    • CEOs of systemically important firms should have “skin in the game” on both the upside and downside—ideally risking personal wealth if their firms become “too big to fail.”
    • Executive comp in companies you’d never sell should be tied to real value creation, with option strike prices set at pre-deal intrinsic values.
  5. Maintain a Chief Risk Officer Mindset
    • Always ask yourself: “Could any one event or business I own blow up Berkshire?” If so, rethink the bet.
    • It’s better to earn low single-digit returns on float safely than chase outsized returns through leverage or exotic derivatives.
  6. Don’t Let Past Deals Blind You to New Opportunities
    • Resist the trap of comparing every new deal to your absolute best—your goal is to do the best you can today, not beat your own record.
    • Market conditions and opportunity costs change, so treat each acquisition as a standalone decision.
  7. Evaluate Businesses on Tangible Returns, Not Goodwill
    • When judging a business’s quality, look at pre-tax returns on net tangible assets—goodwill obscures the real economics.
    • When judging your capital allocation, include goodwill paid (i.e. the full purchase price) to see whether you truly earned a satisfactory return.
  8. Be Skeptical of Long-Term Projections
    • Formal multi-year earnings forecasts carry a false precision; people with projections tend to assume constant growth even in downturns.
    • Instead, build mental models with plausible ranges—focus on the reliability of the business, not a spreadsheet’s line items out to year 10.
  9. Keep Powder Dry—Cash Is a Strategic Asset
    • Short-term rates may be miserable, but Treasury bills give you instant firepower when attractive deals pop up (e.g., pipeline buyouts on weekends).
    • Never chase extra basis points with commercial paper or fancy instruments if it compromises your ability to move quickly on big opportunities.
  10. Commit to Lifelong Learning Through Reading
  • Communication skills—orally and in writing—are the foundation of persuading, negotiating, and understanding complex businesses.
  • Read widely and deeply (annual reports, books, newspapers); even if you’re not fast, consistent reading compounds your knowledge over decades.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *